What is the amount of time a suspected woman needs to be secluded to be considered a Sotah?












2















The Gemara lists a series of opinions (9 by my count) in Sotah 4a as to how long the amount of secluded time must be for a forewarned woman to be considered a potential Sotah.



Do we know which Tanna we pasken like and practically speaking, what amount of time this would be considered nowadays?






halacha talmud-gemara sotah-secluded-woman yichud-seclusion tractate-sotah







share|improve this question




















  • 1





    A starting point might be Even Ha'ezer 178:4 (courtesy of Eyn Mishpat)

    – b a
    5 hours ago
















2















The Gemara lists a series of opinions (9 by my count) in Sotah 4a as to how long the amount of secluded time must be for a forewarned woman to be considered a potential Sotah.



Do we know which Tanna we pasken like and practically speaking, what amount of time this would be considered nowadays?






halacha talmud-gemara sotah-secluded-woman yichud-seclusion tractate-sotah







share|improve this question




















  • 1





    A starting point might be Even Ha'ezer 178:4 (courtesy of Eyn Mishpat)

    – b a
    5 hours ago














2












2








2








The Gemara lists a series of opinions (9 by my count) in Sotah 4a as to how long the amount of secluded time must be for a forewarned woman to be considered a potential Sotah.



Do we know which Tanna we pasken like and practically speaking, what amount of time this would be considered nowadays?






halacha talmud-gemara sotah-secluded-woman yichud-seclusion tractate-sotah







share|improve this question
















The Gemara lists a series of opinions (9 by my count) in Sotah 4a as to how long the amount of secluded time must be for a forewarned woman to be considered a potential Sotah.



Do we know which Tanna we pasken like and practically speaking, what amount of time this would be considered nowadays?






halacha talmud-gemara sotah-secluded-woman yichud-seclusion tractate-sotah




halacha talmud-gemara sotah-secluded-woman yichud-seclusion tractate-sotah






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 5 hours ago









user15464

4,614957




4,614957










asked 6 hours ago









alichtalicht

70416




70416








  • 1





    A starting point might be Even Ha'ezer 178:4 (courtesy of Eyn Mishpat)

    – b a
    5 hours ago














  • 1





    A starting point might be Even Ha'ezer 178:4 (courtesy of Eyn Mishpat)

    – b a
    5 hours ago








1




1





A starting point might be Even Ha'ezer 178:4 (courtesy of Eyn Mishpat)

– b a
5 hours ago





A starting point might be Even Ha'ezer 178:4 (courtesy of Eyn Mishpat)

– b a
5 hours ago










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















3














Rambam Hilchos Sotah 1,2 Paskens like Rabbi Akiva the time for seclusion is to fry an egg and swallow it.




שהתה עמו כדי טומאה שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה הרי זו אסורה על בעלה עד שתשתה מי המרים ויבדק הדבר




Kesef Mishna




ומה שכתב שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה. ברייתא שם (דף ד') פלוגתא ופסק כר"ע:




The Minchas Yitchak 4,94 says this time of seclusion is 5 minutes,

Though the Dvar Halacha teshuva 11 says that this time is merely 35 seconds






share|improve this answer


























  • So in essence machlokes

    – sam
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @sam i think everyone agrees with the Rambam, its just that even sommething obvious to the Rambam is shrouded in mystery nowadays which is why there is such a large time range. don't worry when Elyahu comes he can tell us ho long was the amount as with many added machlokes explaining what the Gemora meant,

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    Minchas yitzchak only says that to be machmir and be yotzei midei safek. even according to him, it should be longer. And I don't know who the devar halacha is but there is no way that you can roast an egg and swallow it in 35 seconds.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @רבותמחשבות do you mean 5 minutes is Machmir to make sure the Chosson satys with the Kalla in the Yichud room?

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    note that many poskim understand the shiur of yichud in general to be longer than the shiur of yichud by a sotah, see R' Moshe's teshuvah.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago



















1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









3














Rambam Hilchos Sotah 1,2 Paskens like Rabbi Akiva the time for seclusion is to fry an egg and swallow it.




שהתה עמו כדי טומאה שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה הרי זו אסורה על בעלה עד שתשתה מי המרים ויבדק הדבר




Kesef Mishna




ומה שכתב שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה. ברייתא שם (דף ד') פלוגתא ופסק כר"ע:




The Minchas Yitchak 4,94 says this time of seclusion is 5 minutes,

Though the Dvar Halacha teshuva 11 says that this time is merely 35 seconds






share|improve this answer


























  • So in essence machlokes

    – sam
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @sam i think everyone agrees with the Rambam, its just that even sommething obvious to the Rambam is shrouded in mystery nowadays which is why there is such a large time range. don't worry when Elyahu comes he can tell us ho long was the amount as with many added machlokes explaining what the Gemora meant,

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    Minchas yitzchak only says that to be machmir and be yotzei midei safek. even according to him, it should be longer. And I don't know who the devar halacha is but there is no way that you can roast an egg and swallow it in 35 seconds.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @רבותמחשבות do you mean 5 minutes is Machmir to make sure the Chosson satys with the Kalla in the Yichud room?

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    note that many poskim understand the shiur of yichud in general to be longer than the shiur of yichud by a sotah, see R' Moshe's teshuvah.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago
















3














Rambam Hilchos Sotah 1,2 Paskens like Rabbi Akiva the time for seclusion is to fry an egg and swallow it.




שהתה עמו כדי טומאה שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה הרי זו אסורה על בעלה עד שתשתה מי המרים ויבדק הדבר




Kesef Mishna




ומה שכתב שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה. ברייתא שם (דף ד') פלוגתא ופסק כר"ע:




The Minchas Yitchak 4,94 says this time of seclusion is 5 minutes,

Though the Dvar Halacha teshuva 11 says that this time is merely 35 seconds






share|improve this answer


























  • So in essence machlokes

    – sam
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @sam i think everyone agrees with the Rambam, its just that even sommething obvious to the Rambam is shrouded in mystery nowadays which is why there is such a large time range. don't worry when Elyahu comes he can tell us ho long was the amount as with many added machlokes explaining what the Gemora meant,

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    Minchas yitzchak only says that to be machmir and be yotzei midei safek. even according to him, it should be longer. And I don't know who the devar halacha is but there is no way that you can roast an egg and swallow it in 35 seconds.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @רבותמחשבות do you mean 5 minutes is Machmir to make sure the Chosson satys with the Kalla in the Yichud room?

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    note that many poskim understand the shiur of yichud in general to be longer than the shiur of yichud by a sotah, see R' Moshe's teshuvah.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago














3












3








3







Rambam Hilchos Sotah 1,2 Paskens like Rabbi Akiva the time for seclusion is to fry an egg and swallow it.




שהתה עמו כדי טומאה שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה הרי זו אסורה על בעלה עד שתשתה מי המרים ויבדק הדבר




Kesef Mishna




ומה שכתב שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה. ברייתא שם (דף ד') פלוגתא ופסק כר"ע:




The Minchas Yitchak 4,94 says this time of seclusion is 5 minutes,

Though the Dvar Halacha teshuva 11 says that this time is merely 35 seconds






share|improve this answer















Rambam Hilchos Sotah 1,2 Paskens like Rabbi Akiva the time for seclusion is to fry an egg and swallow it.




שהתה עמו כדי טומאה שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה הרי זו אסורה על בעלה עד שתשתה מי המרים ויבדק הדבר




Kesef Mishna




ומה שכתב שהוא כדי לצלות ביצה ולגמעה. ברייתא שם (דף ד') פלוגתא ופסק כר"ע:




The Minchas Yitchak 4,94 says this time of seclusion is 5 minutes,

Though the Dvar Halacha teshuva 11 says that this time is merely 35 seconds







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited 4 hours ago

























answered 5 hours ago









user15464user15464

4,614957




4,614957













  • So in essence machlokes

    – sam
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @sam i think everyone agrees with the Rambam, its just that even sommething obvious to the Rambam is shrouded in mystery nowadays which is why there is such a large time range. don't worry when Elyahu comes he can tell us ho long was the amount as with many added machlokes explaining what the Gemora meant,

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    Minchas yitzchak only says that to be machmir and be yotzei midei safek. even according to him, it should be longer. And I don't know who the devar halacha is but there is no way that you can roast an egg and swallow it in 35 seconds.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @רבותמחשבות do you mean 5 minutes is Machmir to make sure the Chosson satys with the Kalla in the Yichud room?

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    note that many poskim understand the shiur of yichud in general to be longer than the shiur of yichud by a sotah, see R' Moshe's teshuvah.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago



















  • So in essence machlokes

    – sam
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @sam i think everyone agrees with the Rambam, its just that even sommething obvious to the Rambam is shrouded in mystery nowadays which is why there is such a large time range. don't worry when Elyahu comes he can tell us ho long was the amount as with many added machlokes explaining what the Gemora meant,

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    Minchas yitzchak only says that to be machmir and be yotzei midei safek. even according to him, it should be longer. And I don't know who the devar halacha is but there is no way that you can roast an egg and swallow it in 35 seconds.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    @רבותמחשבות do you mean 5 minutes is Machmir to make sure the Chosson satys with the Kalla in the Yichud room?

    – user15464
    4 hours ago






  • 1





    note that many poskim understand the shiur of yichud in general to be longer than the shiur of yichud by a sotah, see R' Moshe's teshuvah.

    – רבות מחשבות
    4 hours ago

















So in essence machlokes

– sam
4 hours ago





So in essence machlokes

– sam
4 hours ago




1




1





@sam i think everyone agrees with the Rambam, its just that even sommething obvious to the Rambam is shrouded in mystery nowadays which is why there is such a large time range. don't worry when Elyahu comes he can tell us ho long was the amount as with many added machlokes explaining what the Gemora meant,

– user15464
4 hours ago





@sam i think everyone agrees with the Rambam, its just that even sommething obvious to the Rambam is shrouded in mystery nowadays which is why there is such a large time range. don't worry when Elyahu comes he can tell us ho long was the amount as with many added machlokes explaining what the Gemora meant,

– user15464
4 hours ago




1




1





Minchas yitzchak only says that to be machmir and be yotzei midei safek. even according to him, it should be longer. And I don't know who the devar halacha is but there is no way that you can roast an egg and swallow it in 35 seconds.

– רבות מחשבות
4 hours ago





Minchas yitzchak only says that to be machmir and be yotzei midei safek. even according to him, it should be longer. And I don't know who the devar halacha is but there is no way that you can roast an egg and swallow it in 35 seconds.

– רבות מחשבות
4 hours ago




1




1





@רבותמחשבות do you mean 5 minutes is Machmir to make sure the Chosson satys with the Kalla in the Yichud room?

– user15464
4 hours ago





@רבותמחשבות do you mean 5 minutes is Machmir to make sure the Chosson satys with the Kalla in the Yichud room?

– user15464
4 hours ago




1




1





note that many poskim understand the shiur of yichud in general to be longer than the shiur of yichud by a sotah, see R' Moshe's teshuvah.

– רבות מחשבות
4 hours ago





note that many poskim understand the shiur of yichud in general to be longer than the shiur of yichud by a sotah, see R' Moshe's teshuvah.

– רבות מחשבות
4 hours ago



-

Popular posts from this blog

What other Star Trek series did the main TNG cast show up in?

Image
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty{ margin-bottom:0; } 4 I'm referring to Picard, Riker, Data, Worf, Geordi, Dr. Crusher, Wesley Crusher, Chief O'Brien and family, Deanna Troi, Guinan. I know Picard and Worf show up on DS9, though I haven't seen it myself. I'm curious what happened to the characters after that last episode of TNG? star-trek star-trek-tng share | improve this question edited 10 hours ago Ham Sandwich 6,051 2 25 75 ...
Read more

Berlina muro

Image
La berlina muro ĉe Bethaniendamm, 1986 La berlina muro aŭ simple la muro [1] , nomita ankaŭ "kontraŭfaŝisma remparo" en propaganda lingvo de la iama Germana Demokratia Respubliko, estis parto de la interngermana limo, kiu dividis de la 13-a de aŭgusto 1961 ĝis la 9-a de novembro 1989 okcidentan Berlinon de la orienta parto de la urbo kaj de la ĉirkaŭa tereno de la GDR. Ĝi estis unu el la plej famaj simboloj de la malvarma milito kaj de la disdivido de Germanio. Pli ol simpla muro, la berlina muro estis fakte tuta defendokonstruaĵo kun du muroj, ena malplena strio, rondirvojo, gardturoj kaj alarmsistemoj. Dum la provo transiri la severe garditan limon al okcidenta Berlino multaj homoj estis mortigitaj. La preciza nombro de viktimoj estas pridisputita kaj ne certa; la nombroj anoncataj varias inter 86 kaj 238 mortintoj. La malplifortiĝo de Sovetunio kaj la politiko de liberigo gvidita de Miĥail Gorbaĉov ebligis al la orientgermanoj faligi la 9-an de novembro 1989 l...
Read more

Berlina aerponto

Image
Flugkoridoroj dum la blokado de Berlino La Berlina aerponto estas la provizigo de okcidenta Berlino per aviadiloj fare de la aliancanoj inter la 23-a de junio 1948 kaj la 12-a de majo 1949 dum la blokado de Berlino fare de la sovetia armeo. Enhavo 1 Historio 1.1 La aerkoridoroj 1.2 Unuaj flugoj 1.3 Plibonigo de la aerponto 1.4 Fino de la aerponto 1.5 Rozinbombiloj 1.6 Bilanco 2 Flughavenoj 2.1 Berlino 2.2 Okcidenta Germanio 3 Aviadiloj de la berlina aerponto 4 15-a datreveno de la aerponto 5 Bibliografio 6 Referencoj 7 Eksteraj ligiloj Historio | General Lucius D. Clay, militguberniestro de la usona okupadzono Jam antaŭ la berlina aerponto estiĝis la malgranda aerponto . La estro de la sovetia militadministracio en Germanio, Vasili Daniloviĉ Sokolovski, ordonis la 1-an de aprilo 1948, kiel reago al la konferenco de Londono inter britoj, francoj kaj reprezentantoj de Benelukso pri aligo de Germa...
Read more